Submission is attached.
Independent Review of the Australia Public Service
Cancer Council is Australia’s peak national non-government cancer control organisation
and advises the Australian Government and other bodies on evidence-based practices and
policies to help prevent, detect and treat cancer.
Australian Oncology Social Work Inc. (OSWA) is a non-profit, incorporated national
organisation dedicated to the enhancement of psychosocial services to people with cancer
and their families.
Cancer Council and OSWA welcome the invitation to submit to the Independent Review of the
Australian Public Service, specifically to address point 5 of the Terms of Reference:
Improving citizens experience of government and deliver fair outcomes for them.
Cancer Council and OSWA use this opportunity to recommend changes to how people
affected by cancer, interface with the welfare system through:
- Introducing a single point of contact to access all welfare options.
- Introducing a case management model to assist individuals to navigate the welfare system
efficiently and effectively.
Hospitals, community settings and Centrelink provide the infrastructure to enable a case
management, central point of contact approach to the provision of information, application and
ongoing management of welfare cases to reduce financial hardship for people affected by
cancer. The issues and recommendations presented in this submission are equally applicable
for people with chronic illnesses other than cancer.
Key welfare issues for people affected by cancer
A change in financial situation is a significant concern for people affected by cancer. Patients
are often unaware of their options, such as financial assistance, and hardship arrangements,
and have trouble accessing available welfare on their own. This inability to act can place
people into financial hardship. Our interest in this matter is centred on the reality that
Australian’s in the lowest socio-economic quintile are 30% more likely to die from their cancer
than those in the highest socio-economic group, even when controlling for type of cancer and
stage at diagnosis. Poverty and financial hardship directly impact on whether someone will
survive from cancer.
Cancer Council offers a national telephone information and support service (13 11 20) for
people affected by cancer to seek practical, emotional and informational support about their
disease and managing its physical and social implications. Increasingly, calls to 13 11 20 are
received from people with financial concerns, requiring direct financial assistance or financial
Cancer Council & OSWA 3REDACTEDPage 1 of 7
counselling to manage unanticipated and often debilitating out of pocket expenses associated
with cancer. Issues relating to finance, legal and practical support represent 30% of calls
nationally (14,157 calls per annum). Often these calls relate to accessing benefits or
negotiating early access to superannuation.
In response to increased demand, Cancer Council established a pilot financial navigation
service in one state to conduct rapid needs assessment and link people to an appropriate
service, including Centrelink. In the first year of operation, the financial navigation service
received 1,804 calls for assistance or guidance. Of these calls, the majority (38%) were related
to the need for emergency assistance in the form of bill payments such as car insurance and
utilities, or food vouchers due to displacement of funds related to cancer care or inability to
attend paid employment for self or a family member. An additional 30% of callers sought to
discuss their financial situation and explore their options with a financial professional. A further
20% of calls were made from social workers and health professionals to discuss services and
resources available on behalf of their patients.
Many clients are unaware of their eligibility for assistance. Confusion about eligibility can
discourage a low-income patient from considering an application for assistance. Alternatively,
people who are already receiving unemployment or income support may have their eligibility
status change due to illness. Financial counsellors at Cancer Council identify possible options,
including Government welfare programs, for their clients.
Inability for people with cancer to easily navigate the welfare system to access
disability and unemployment benefits.
People affected by cancer often experience a sudden and immediate change in their ability to
generate income, which affects their family and capacity to continue to pay usual bills and
financial commitments. This is often compounded by medical expenses, even when fully
treated in the public healthcare system. Although their ability to work changes, their usual bills
do not and often increase.
Common issues reported by patients related to their experience of Government funded welfare
programs (Centrelink, the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) and My Aged Care)
are listed below:
Practical elements related to access of information about available welfare options:
• Highly digital benefit application systems require people to call automated voice
systems or have access to a computer. This assumes a degree of computer literacy,
numeracy skills and clarity of mind as it also requires recall of personal log in, pin codes
and passwords. Telephone access is particularly limiting for patients with
communication difficulties such as those resulting from head and neck cancer.
• Visiting the Centrelink office is time consuming and overwhelming for many people,
but particularly difficult for people affected by mobility issues due to illness or treatment.
People unwell from cancer are least able to tolerate an extended visit to an office.
Often people affected by blood based cancers are immune-suppressed and on
medical advice, must avoid public settings, at times for months.
• Limited availability of interpreters for people where English is not their first language.
Cancer Council & OSWA 3REDACTEDPage 2 of 7
Complex and confusing application processes:
• Each Government welfare program is administered in isolation of other schemes,
requiring individual applications and assessment.
• Difficulty accessing appropriate welfare options despite lodgement of written letters of
support from health professionals about the diagnosis and, or the effects of the
condition on employment. Terminology used by the doctor is critical to the success of
the claim and wrong terminology may mean starting again.
• Time delays in welfare access can be compounded by the need to submit further
documentation.
• No transparency of the estimated wait time and/or status of applications within the
review process.
• No emergency assistance available to high need applicants during the review process.
• Information about the reason for rejection or the processes for appeal are not routinely
provided. People report that advice of an alternative claim option is not provided, which
leads them to believe they have no entitlement to income or other support.
• Interaction with multiple Centrelink officers, leading to telling the story over again, and
can create high levels of discouragement in the application process and sometimes
abandonment.
• Difficulty obtaining an appointment with Centrelink social workers. A claims issue can
be solved quickly by a hospital social worker with assistance of a Centrelink Worker or
Community Liaison Officer but these resources seem limited.
• Expiration of a medical certificate and discontinuation of payment without warning. This
is particularly problematic for people who are unwell, hospitalised for long periods,
geographically isolated and away from home, as well as for socially marginalised and
vulnerable population.
These issues are stepped out in the way of case examples from people who have contacted
Cancer Council (all names have been altered)
Paul, 49, was diagnosed with advanced kidney cancer which had advanced into his brain,
spine and both lungs. Due to the diagnosis and advanced nature of illness Paul was
unable to continue work. Paul lived with his wife Melanie and their young child. Melanie,
as the primary carer for Paul, was forced to reduce her work hours resulting in a sharp
decline in their income. Managing mortgage repayments and daily expenses became
difficult and led to severe stress. Increased out of pocket expenses related to travelling
and accommodation for treatment are making it difficult for them to make ends meet.
Cancer Council NSW Financial Assistance Services team assisted the family to address
their primary financial concerns and financial counsellors provided them with options and
information to better manage their change in financial situation. They informed them about
Income Protection and managed mortgage stress. Assistance was provided with payment
of car registration and unpaid telephone and water bills through the Emergency Financial
Assistance Program. The client was then referred to Pro Bono Financial Planning Service
to assist with accessing Income Protection.Good case management includes reviewing
individual circumstances and advising on the options that would benefit the client. In this
scenario Paul may have avoided unnecessary application to Centrelink as the Cancer
Council linked him with a financial planner who identified that he was ineligible and would
benefit from different assistance.
Cancer Council & OSWA 3REDACTEDPage 3 of 7
Sophie, 53, from Queensland relays a story about being told she could call and speak to
Centrelink Social Workers for assistance with the application process, but when calling the
number for the social worker, none of the options on the Centrelink voice message matched
to social work. When she chose a different option, the system would not allow the call to
progress, and the call ended. This made her feel like she couldn’t access social work or
support from Centrelink and was left feeling frustrated and anxious, and like she wasn’t
entitled to receive assistance. Referral to the Cancer Council pro bono financial service
linked her to a financial planner who could review her case and guide Sophie to the
assistance she was entitled to.
A cancer diagnosis can have implications for low income earners with an existing income
assistance arrangement. They may be required to revise arrangements due to illness.
However, they are either unaware of the implications or have compromised ability to engage
in the process, resulting in stoppage of regular payments. Although this is a system-wide
issue, it has a substantial impact on cancer patients who often require immediate assistance
after a diagnosis. Recently, an Australian newspaper reported that a man with bowel cancer
had his Newstart Allowance removed as he was no longer able to meet the reporting
requirements or achieve the minimum job applications conditions of the program while he was
undergoing cancer treatmenti. In this example, the patient was too ill to negotiate a change to
his arrangements. With the availability of a case manager, this man could have been
transitioned to a sickness allowance without delay to regular income support. Improved
coordination of a person’s needs during different situations would reduce delay in access to
financial assistance and exacerbate their experience of financial distress.
‘Intent to claim’ process for earlier access to support:
We are concerned by the recent changes to the ‘intent to claim’ processii. Under the ‘intent to
claim’ process people had their payments backdated to the date of first contact with Centrelink.
Under the new arrangements, some claimants may no longer be able to commence the
application process prior to lodging all the necessary forms and identification documents.
People who have difficulty finalising their paperwork due to reasons of illness (and sometimes
inability to proceed with their claim altogether), may lose several weeks of benefit payments.
This disadvantages people who are acutely unwell, hospitalised for long period,
geographically isolated and away from home, as well as those who are socially marginalised
and vulnerable, including homeless or transient people.
The impact of current access pathways to financial support in the form of welfare
payments on patients and families.
Vulnerable people may cease pursing their entitlements if they do not have an advocate to
assist them. Carers are another vulnerable group who may not pursue an application for
support when it becomes difficult.
Myriam and her three sons, unable to speak English, arrived in Australia as refugees from
Iraq. She was diagnosed with cancer of the larynx and underwent a laryngectomy with
tracheostomy and palliative radiation. She was unable to communicate via phone, only in
person due to the impact on her vocal chords. Her youngest son was appointed as power
of attorney, and was working shifts at McDonalds around school to support his mother and
Cancer Council & OSWA 3REDACTEDPage 4 of 7
brothers. On referral to Cancer Council for financial assistance and help with a will, Myriam
was behind on her rent, and at imminent risk of having her utilities cut off. There were also
a number of debt demands, with money being prioritised for these over providing food for
herself and her family. She was receiving Centrelink benefits, but these were ceased when
she became unwell while visiting family overseas, meaning she could not return to Australia
within the required timeframe to continue access. Cancer Council was able to work with
Myriam and other community organisations to:
-
Provide financial counselling about how to reinstate Centrelink and other ongoing
supports -
Put a temporary hold on rent and utility payments via advocacy to her housing
manager and the Health Ombudsmen while hardship programs were explored - Provide referral to pro bono services for access and support with writing a will
-
Provide food vouchers to the value of $300 via Cancer Council Financial Assistance
Program.Cancer Council was a central point of contact in this case. The financial navigation service
arranged access to support services as well as being an advocate to institutions to ensure
debt could be managed while benefits reinstatement was pursued.
Delay in receiving benefits:
The time taken to process claims can leave people without an income for a significant period.
Where illness is the reason for a Centrelink application, the loss of income has usually been
sudden and unanticipated. During this time patients must maintain upkeep of basic living
expenses which can be increased by additional costs associated with attending treatment
centres and paying for medical treatment and tests. Patients who relocate from rural or
regional areas before their claim has been assessed can be particularly disadvantaged due to
a need to resolve claim issues remotely. Change in financial situation may result in people
delaying investigations to confirm a cancer diagnosis, making sub-optimal treatment choices
based on ineligibility for income support or being unable to pay for support services. This may
contribute to a compromised ability to adhere to treatment recommendations due to financial
burden. The decision to forego recommended treatment is likely to contribute to the 30%
higher aged-standardised cancer mortality experienced by disadvantaged peopleiii. A poorly
navigable welfare system can worsen survivorship and wellness prospects for people
diagnosed with cancer.
Recommendations for improving the experience of welfare in the public system.
Below is a list of recommendations to be considered by the panel.
- Implement a coordinated case management approach to welfare across all Government
programs to support provision of individualised information, application assistance, and
ongoing management of access to welfare, for people affected by cancer.
A welfare case manager would be assigned to each client who currently accesses
Government assistance, and representatives would be available in hospitals to discuss
welfare options with newly diagnosed, low income patients.
For low income earners, not currently accessing benefits, this model would enable:
• Increased service provision to reduce waiting times and improve ease of access.
Cancer Council & OSWA 3REDACTEDPage 5 of 7
• Improved access to welfare options for people who are on the border of being eligible.
• A streamlined system allowing health professionals access to Centrelink personnel to
confirm or update client information.
• Clearer direction toward available options for younger people.
Additional recommendation for existing welfare recipients:
• Relaxing the reporting requirements for low income earners on welfare undergoing
cancer treatment, with a simplified mechanism for confirming treatment arrangements
and duration without interruption to payments.
This may require employment of additional Community Engagement Officers by Centrelink to
enable personnel to visit patients in hospital or at home to facilitate their claim process.
-
Fast track claims for people in minority populations or people at risk high of financial
hardship, based on immediate or urgent need. -
Provision of services, such as improved access to interpreters, to support culturally and
linguistically diverse access to services. -
Re-introduce ‘Intent of Claim’ scheme to enable earlier commencement of applications,
and payment of entitlements from when the situation changed. -
Undertake a full review of Centrelink processes and protocols, including:
• Ensuring accessibility to these programs for vulnerable populations, experiencing the
greatest need.
• Classification of cancer as a chronic and debilitating disease, creating long term
financial implications.
• Gaps in access for people who are borderline eligible.
• Emergency assistance for high need clients.
• Transport allowance or subsidy for people receiving an income payment undergoing
chemotherapy or radiation therapy.
• Increase in, and equitable access to, social workers across the health system who are
resourced to provide more comprehensive support to people affected by cancer.
We would welcome further discussion about this submission to reduce the burden faced by
people affected by cancer. We believe the skills and services offered by our organisations can
be of direct relevance to an improved Centrelink service and greater levels of engagement
between our organisations.
Professor Sanchia Aranda Ms Kim Hobbs
CEO, Cancer Council Australia Clinical Specialist Social Worker
Westmead Hospital, Sydney
Cancer Council & OSWA 3REDACTEDPage 6 of 7
Contact:
Kate Whittaker, Manager, Cancer Care Policy, Cancer Council Australia 02 8063 4161
Kim Hobbs, Clinical Specialist Social Worker, and member of OSWA Executive 02 9845 6699
i
Pro Bono Australia Man battling cancer and Centrelink raises social media storm, published 10th July 2018,
accessible via https://probonoaustralia.com.au/news/2018/07/man-battling-cancer-centrelink-raises-social-
media-storm/
ii
Department of Human Services. Intent to claim is stopping on 1 July 2018 published 5 June 2018,
Commonwealth Government. Accessible via https://www.humanservices.gov.au/individuals/news/intent-
claim-stopping-1-july-2018
iii
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare 2017. Cancer in Australia 2017. Cancer series no.101. Cat. no. CAN
- Canberra: AIHW.
Cancer Council & OSWA 3REDACTEDPage 7 of 7